Log in Subscribe

If It Ain’t Broke, Why Is Craig Skinner Fixing It?

Posted

(LEXINGTON, Ky.) — Craig Skinner has won nine consecutive Southeastern Conference volleyball championships. He's captured a national title, built Kentucky into a perennial powerhouse, and turned a sport that once drew fewer people than my book signings into one of the hottest tickets in town.

So naturally, it's time to change things.

I know—that sounds about as sensible as replacing the engine in a perfectly good Cadillac because the radio occasionally picks up static. But as Kentucky prepares for the SEC Tournament in Savannah, Skinner faces the kind of decision that separates good coaches from great ones. Does he stick with the players and combinations that brought him this far, or does he risk bruising a few egos in pursuit of something bigger?

Because here's the uncomfortable truth about Kentucky volleyball. Winning the SEC has become almost routine. Kentucky has become a victim of its own success. For Skinner and crew, the expectations have reached national championship-or-bust territory.

And the old winning formula, as successful as it's been, might need an upgrade.

The warning signs weren't exactly subtle. Tennessee rallied from two sets down to stun Kentucky, and Texas A&M followed by sweeping the Wildcats right out of their kneepads on their home court. Six consecutive lost sets. Suddenly, the machine that had been humming along so beautifully looked like my old iPhone 14—still capable of impressive things, provided you didn't ask it to perform under pressure.

Skinner didn't panic. He didn't publicly throw his players under the bus or start shopping for replacements on Amazon Prime. Instead, he demanded greater urgency in practice, more accountability, and better execution on every point. Kentucky responded with five consecutive sweeps to close out the regular season at 20-5, 12-3 SEC.

But improvement isn't always about practicing harder. Sometimes it's about changing who plays, where they play, and how much they play.

Consider Morgan Gaerte's move to the left side.

Skinner explained that he initially believed Kentucky was fine after one loss. But after a couple more setbacks, he decided the Wildcats needed more reliable attacking options.

"The goal is to try and have at least three options available every time you receive serve," Skinner explained.

With Gaerte and Brooklyn DeLeye posting Kentucky's highest kill percentages, positioning both where they could remain consistently available made sense.

"Having them available all the time has been important," Skinner said, explaining that Gaerte and DeLeye could still bail Kentucky out when its serve receive struggled.

In other words, a winning lineup isn't a family heirloom. You don't preserve it simply because Grandma liked it that way.

All 17 players on Kentucky's roster have worked hard enough to believe they deserve to be on the court. Every starter has earned a measure of trust. Every reserve wants an opportunity. Unfortunately, there are only so many meaningful rotations to go around, and the NCAA has yet to approve a participation trophy for everybody who shows up.

Sometimes, somebody's rotations may have to shrink so somebody else's can grow.

That's not a punishment. That's where coaching comes in.

The easy thing is to preserve the status quo, keep everybody reasonably happy, and hope your established lineup catches fire when the postseason arrives. The harder thing is to look a player in the eye, acknowledge everything she's contributed, and explain why the team might be better with a different combination. Nobody enjoys that conversation, especially the player on the receiving end. But the best coaches aren't running popularity contests. They're making decisions that give their teams the best chance to win.

I'm not suggesting Skinner should overhaul his lineup simply to prove he's capable of making changes. That's how coaches wind up outsmarting themselves. Nor am I pretending to know which players deserve more opportunities and which should surrender them. I've spent enough time sitting in the peanut gallery to recognize that the view from there doesn't come with a coaching degree.

But championship teams rarely reach their potential by standing still.

The SEC Tournament offers an intriguing opportunity to find out whether Kentucky's recent improvement is real. As the No. 2 seed, the Wildcats receive a double bye into Sunday's 5 PM EST (SEC Network) quarterfinals, where they could encounter a familiar tormentor.

Texas A&M.

Now wouldn't that be delicious?

I couldn't resist asking Skinner whether he'd be cheering for the Aggies to advance and provide Kentucky with a revenge opportunity.

"I don't think I've ever cheered for another SEC team," he replied.

Fair enough. Good answer, Coach.

Still, a rematch would be revealing. The Aggies exposed Kentucky's weaknesses in serve receive, blocking, and transition offense. Another meeting would offer something more valuable than revenge: proof that Skinner's adjustments have addressed the problems that got the Wildcats into trouble.

Of course, Savannah isn't the ultimate destination. Another SEC trophy would be nice, but Kentucky has bigger ambitions. Reaching them may require uncomfortable adjustments, wounded pride, and a few difficult conversations.

There's a fine line between consistency and stubbornness.

The best coaches know when to cross it.

And if Skinner's willingness to make a few uncomfortable changes leads to another national championship, I doubt anybody will complain about who started, who sat, or whose rotations were reduced.

They'll be too busy admiring the trophy.

 

Dr. John Huang is a retired orthodontist, military veteran, and award-winning author. He currently serves as a columnist for Nolan Group Media and invites readers to follow him on social media @KYHuangs. His latest book is Whining for Posterity, available on Amazon.

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here